VIS Concrete Design | Secondary Members


SECONDARY MEMBERS Hello everybody. In this video we will talk
about secondary members. According to EC8 Section 4.2.2, Secondary Seismic Members are
those not part of the Seismic Action Resisting System of the building. To summarize EC8 requirements: secondary members
should not take seismic forces away from the seismic resisting system and need not be designed
for these forces, however they need to keep providing vertical load support while subject
to seismic displacement. Strength and stiffness of secondary members
against seismic actions are to be neglected Secondary members need be designed for gravity
loads only While subject to seismic displacement, secondary
members need to be capable of supporting the gravity portion of seismic load combinations. How to accomplish all this is rather complex.
Here is an example with a possible approach, starting from a SAP2000 model. In the example we will tweak the analysis
a little, adopting the one-step stage construction option (already available at the SAP entry
level). The intent is to assign hinges at the end of all secondary beams during the
seismic situation. This will allow us to meet provision A. First, let us create groups identifying primary
and secondary members. In this example we choose to treat the interior beams as secondary
members. Everything else we’ll consider primary. Next, let us define a property set, where
moments are released at both ends of a member. Then, let us set up a stage construction case,
where that property set is assigned to all secondary members. We are also imposing reduced
inertia to all members. The gravity analysis cases should start from
the zero condition and the modal analysis case should start after the staged construction;
the response spectrum analysis needs to be based on this modal analysis. Now let us take care of provision C. Run the
analysis. Look at the rotations of the joints of secondary
beams from the response spectrum case in the Y direction. They are all pretty much around
.00045 radians. These rotations need be multiplied by the structure behavior factor q, in our
case 2.64. The result is a rotation of 0.0012 radians. Let us isolate a single secondary beam and
apply that rotation at the two ends. The resulting moment is 30.9 KN-m. Now go back to the original model and create
a load pattern where that moment is applied at the ends of all secondary beams. Let us make a load case where that pattern
is applied at the end of the stage construction case. In the load combinations, add this to
the response spectrum case in the Y direction with both the plus and minus signs. Basically, we are making sure that the secondary
beams, in addition to the vertical loads, can take the forces deriving from the seismic
displacement. This rather conservative approach is suggested by Section 5.7 of EC8. Finally, let us run the analysis and start
VIS, and we’ll take care of provision B. Simply select the groups inherited from the
SAP model and tell VIS which members are to be considered primary or secondary. VIS automatically excludes from design of
secondary members all capacity design requirements. Only strength design and general construction
detailing requirements are applied. Secondary members will still be subject to
seismic load combinations, but with the limitations above. Run the VIS Wizard and look at the results.
These are from our analysis with secondary members. These are from a regular analysis
(that is, one with no secondary members). As you can see, while the longitudinal reinforcing
remains pretty much the same, the transverse reinforcing is lower when secondary members
are considered. Now, that was well and good, but the real
game changer is what happens to primary members. Since secondary members do not take part in
the seismic action, they do not affect capacity design of primary members, in our case columns
and joint panels. Their reinforcing in the weak direction gets a nice bonus! This concludes our presentation. To the next
Video! Thank you, for your attention.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *