Vindman: Trump-Ukraine Call Record Omitted Biden-Related Mentions | Rachel Maddow | MSNBC


>>>BECAUSE IT’S A DAY SINCE>>>BECAUSE IT’S A DAY SINCE WE’VE BEEN ON THE AIR THERE’S WE’VE BEEN ON THE AIR THERE’S NEW BREAKING NEWS TO BRING YOU NEW BREAKING NEWS TO BRING YOU TONIGHT. TONIGHT. THIS TIME IT’S THE “THE NEW YORK THIS TIME IT’S THE “THE NEW YORK TIMES” THAT’S JUST BROKEN NEWS, TIMES” THAT’S JUST BROKEN NEWS, SOME FAIRLY EXPLOSIVE NEWS ABOUT SOME FAIRLY EXPLOSIVE NEWS ABOUT THE TESTIMONY THAT JUST WRAPPED THE TESTIMONY THAT JUST WRAPPED UP TODAY FROM LIEUTENANT COLONEL UP TODAY FROM LIEUTENANT COLONEL ALEXANDER VINDMAN WHO’S THE TOP ALEXANDER VINDMAN WHO’S THE TOP UKRAINIAN EXPERT ON THE NATIONAL UKRAINIAN EXPERT ON THE NATIONAL SECURITY COUNSEL. SECURITY COUNSEL. WE KNOW BECAUSE “THE NEW YORK WE KNOW BECAUSE “THE NEW YORK TIMES” WAS THE FIRST TO REPORT TIMES” WAS THE FIRST TO REPORT LAST NIGHT ON THE CONTENT OF LAST NIGHT ON THE CONTENT OF COLONEL VINDMAN’S OPENING COLONEL VINDMAN’S OPENING STATEMENT. STATEMENT. WE KNOW HE WAS DUE TO TELL WE KNOW HE WAS DUE TO TELL CONGRESS TODAY IN THE CONGRESS TODAY IN THE IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDINGS ABOUT IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDINGS ABOUT HIS CONCERNS AND THE FACT HE HIS CONCERNS AND THE FACT HE RAISED AN INTERNAL ALARM AFTER RAISED AN INTERNAL ALARM AFTER LISTENING IN ON THE PRESIDENT’S LISTENING IN ON THE PRESIDENT’S CALL TO THE PRESIDENT OF UKRAINE CALL TO THE PRESIDENT OF UKRAINE BECAUSE HE BELIEVED WHAT HE BECAUSE HE BELIEVED WHAT HE HEARD WAS IMPROPER AND HE HEARD WAS IMPROPER AND HE REPORTED IT UP THE CHAIN OF REPORTED IT UP THE CHAIN OF COMMAND. COMMAND. NOW ACCORDING TO “THE NEW YORK NOW ACCORDING TO “THE NEW YORK TIMES” WE’VE GOT MORE DETAIL AS TIMES” WE’VE GOT MORE DETAIL AS TO WHAT COLONEL VINDMAN TO WHAT COLONEL VINDMAN TESTIFIED ABOUT. TESTIFIED ABOUT. LET ME JUST TELL YOU WHAT THE LET ME JUST TELL YOU WHAT THE LEAD OF THEIR PIECE IS. LEAD OF THEIR PIECE IS. QUOTE, LIEUTENANT COLONEL QUOTE, LIEUTENANT COLONEL ALEXANDER VINDMAN TOLD HOUSE ALEXANDER VINDMAN TOLD HOUSE IMPEACHMENT INVESTIGATORS TODAY IMPEACHMENT INVESTIGATORS TODAY THAT THE WHITE HOUSE TRANSCRIPT THAT THE WHITE HOUSE TRANSCRIPT OF A JULY CALL BETWEEN PRESIDENT OF A JULY CALL BETWEEN PRESIDENT TRUMP AND UKRAINE’S PRESIDENT TRUMP AND UKRAINE’S PRESIDENT OMITTED CRUCIAL WORDS AND OMITTED CRUCIAL WORDS AND PHRASES AND THAT HIS ATTEMPTS TO PHRASES AND THAT HIS ATTEMPTS TO RESTORE THEM FAILED. RESTORE THEM FAILED. CITING THREE PEOPLE FAMILIAR CITING THREE PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH THE TESTIMONY, THEY WITH THE TESTIMONY, THEY DESCRIBED THIS BASIC PROCESS. DESCRIBED THIS BASIC PROCESS. “THE TIMES” SAYS, QUOTE, THERE’S “THE TIMES” SAYS, QUOTE, THERE’S NO RECORDING OF THE CALL AND NO RECORDING OF THE CALL AND NOTE TAKING AS WELL AS VOICE NOTE TAKING AS WELL AS VOICE RECOGNITION SOFTWARE BUT NAMES RECOGNITION SOFTWARE BUT NAMES AND TECHNICAL TERMS ARE AND TECHNICAL TERMS ARE FREQUENTLY MISSED BY THE FREQUENTLY MISSED BY THE SOFTWARE ACCORDING TO PEOPLE SOFTWARE ACCORDING TO PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH THE MATTER. FAMILIAR WITH THE MATTER. AFTER THE CALL TOOK PLACE IN AFTER THE CALL TOOK PLACE IN WHICH COLONEL VINDMAN LISTENED WHICH COLONEL VINDMAN LISTENED IN HE WAS GIVEN A HARD COPY OF IN HE WAS GIVEN A HARD COPY OF THE ROUGH TRANSCRIPT TO MAKE THE ROUGH TRANSCRIPT TO MAKE UPDATES AND CORRECTIONS. UPDATES AND CORRECTIONS. COLONEL VINDMAN WENT THROUGH THE COLONEL VINDMAN WENT THROUGH THE TRANSCRIPT, MADE CHANGES AND TRANSCRIPT, MADE CHANGES AND GAVE HIS WRITTEN EDITS TO HIS GAVE HIS WRITTEN EDITS TO HIS BOSS, TIMOTHY MORRISON, WHO’S BOSS, TIMOTHY MORRISON, WHO’S THE CURRENT DIRECTOR OF RUSSIAN THE CURRENT DIRECTOR OF RUSSIAN AND EUROPEAN AFFAIRS AT THE AND EUROPEAN AFFAIRS AT THE SECURITY COUNSEL. SECURITY COUNSEL. BUT IN TERM OF WHAT VINDMAN BUT IN TERM OF WHAT VINDMAN TRIED TO CORRECT IN THAT TRIED TO CORRECT IN THAT TESTIMONY, THIS IS EXPLOSIVE, TESTIMONY, THIS IS EXPLOSIVE, THE OMISSIONS COLONEL VINDMAN THE OMISSIONS COLONEL VINDMAN SAID INCLUDED PRESIDENT TRUMP’S SAID INCLUDED PRESIDENT TRUMP’S ASSERTION THAT THERE WERE ASSERTION THAT THERE WERE RECORDINGS OF JOE BIDEN RECORDINGS OF JOE BIDEN DISCUSSING UKRAINE CORRUPTION DISCUSSING UKRAINE CORRUPTION AND AN EXPLICIT MENTION BY AND AN EXPLICIT MENTION BY UKRAINE’S PRESIDENT ZELENSKY OF UKRAINE’S PRESIDENT ZELENSKY OF BURISMA HOLDINGS. BURISMA HOLDINGS. COLONEL VINDMAN TOLD THE COLONEL VINDMAN TOLD THE IMPEACHMENT INVESTIGATORS TODAY IMPEACHMENT INVESTIGATORS TODAY HE TRIED TO CHANGE THE HE TRIED TO CHANGE THE CONSTRUCTED TRANSCRIPT MADE BY CONSTRUCTED TRANSCRIPT MADE BY WHITE HOUSE STAFF TO THOSE WHITE HOUSE STAFF TO THOSE OMISSIONS BUT THOSE TWO OMISSIONS BUT THOSE TWO CORRECTIONS WERE NOT MADE. CORRECTIONS WERE NOT MADE. COLONEL VINDMAN — DRIVING COLONEL VINDMAN — DRIVING FURTHER QUESTIONS HOW OFFICIALS FURTHER QUESTIONS HOW OFFICIALS HANDLED THE CALL AND THE HANDLED THE CALL AND THE DECISION TO PUT IT INTO THE DECISION TO PUT IT INTO THE WHITE HOUSE’S MOST CLASSIFIED WHITE HOUSE’S MOST CLASSIFIED COMPUTER SYSTEM AND ALSO DRIVE COMPUTER SYSTEM AND ALSO DRIVE QUESTIONS WHETHER THOSE MOVES QUESTIONS WHETHER THOSE MOVES WERE MEANT TO CONSEAL THE CALL’S WERE MEANT TO CONSEAL THE CALL’S MOST CONTROVERSIAL ASPECTS. MOST CONTROVERSIAL ASPECTS. YEAH, IT WILL. YEAH, IT WILL. JOINING US NOW IS MICHAEL JOINING US NOW IS MICHAEL McFALL, FORMER AMBASSADOR TO McFALL, FORMER AMBASSADOR TO RUSSIA. RUSSIA. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US THANK YOU FOR JOINING US TONIGHT. TONIGHT. I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU MAKING I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU MAKING THE TIME. THE TIME.>>SURE.>>SURE. GLAD TO BE HERE, RACHEL. GLAD TO BE HERE, RACHEL.>>COUPLE OF THINGS GOING ON>>COUPLE OF THINGS GOING ON HERE. HERE. I WANT TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT YOUR I WANT TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT YOUR EXPERIENCE WITH COLONEL VINDMAN, EXPERIENCE WITH COLONEL VINDMAN, YOUR REACTION TO THE WAY HIS YOUR REACTION TO THE WAY HIS TESTIMONY WAS TREATED TODAY. TESTIMONY WAS TREATED TODAY. I DO HAVE TO ASK YOUR REACTION I DO HAVE TO ASK YOUR REACTION TO THE BREAKING NEWS JUST COMING TO THE BREAKING NEWS JUST COMING OUT FROM “THE NEW YORK TIMES” HE OUT FROM “THE NEW YORK TIMES” HE MAY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED AND SEEMS MAY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED AND SEEMS LIKE WAS PROPERLY INVOLVED IN LIKE WAS PROPERLY INVOLVED IN TRYING TO MAKE SURE THE WHITE TRYING TO MAKE SURE THE WHITE HOUSE TRANSCRIPTS SLASH NOTES OF HOUSE TRANSCRIPTS SLASH NOTES OF THAT CALL WERE ACCURATE BUT WHEN THAT CALL WERE ACCURATE BUT WHEN HE TRIED TO MATERIALLY FILL IN HE TRIED TO MATERIALLY FILL IN NOTES LEFT OUT OF THAT NOTES LEFT OUT OF THAT TRANSCRIPT IT WAS REJECTED. TRANSCRIPT IT WAS REJECTED.>>I WORKED THREE YEARS AS THE>>I WORKED THREE YEARS AS THE SENIOR DIRECTOR, LISTENED TO SENIOR DIRECTOR, LISTENED TO MANY PHONE CALLS AND MY MANY PHONE CALLS AND MY DIRECTORS WRITE THE EQUIVALENT, DIRECTORS WRITE THE EQUIVALENT, THEY FREQUENTLY WOULD SIT DOWN THEY FREQUENTLY WOULD SIT DOWN THERE IN THE SITUATION ROOM NEXT THERE IN THE SITUATION ROOM NEXT TO THE TRANSCRIBERS SO THE TO THE TRANSCRIBERS SO THE DIRECTORS WOULD LISTEN AS WELL DIRECTORS WOULD LISTEN AS WELL AND THEN CORRECT THE RECORD JUST AND THEN CORRECT THE RECORD JUST TO MAKE SURE THEY GET ALL THE TO MAKE SURE THEY GET ALL THE FACTS RIGHT, ESPECIALLY AS YOU FACTS RIGHT, ESPECIALLY AS YOU JUST NOTED THE PROPER NOUNS, JUST NOTED THE PROPER NOUNS, RIGHT? RIGHT? WHO KNOWS WHAT BURISMA? WHO KNOWS WHAT BURISMA? THERE’S A GUY WHO DOES KNOW WHAT THERE’S A GUY WHO DOES KNOW WHAT BURISMA IS, IT’S COLONEL BURISMA IS, IT’S COLONEL VINDMAN. VINDMAN. IT’S SUPPOSED TO BE AN OFFICIAL IT’S SUPPOSED TO BE AN OFFICIAL RECORD. RECORD. SO THAT WAS LEFT OUT. SO THAT WAS LEFT OUT. IT IS SHOCKING TO ME. IT IS SHOCKING TO ME. THAT IS NOT STANDARD OPERATING THAT IS NOT STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE. PROCEDURE.>>IF THERE IS A SCANDAL HERE,>>IF THERE IS A SCANDAL HERE, IF THERE IS SOMETHING IF THERE IS SOMETHING POTENTIALLY CRIMINAL HERE IN POTENTIALLY CRIMINAL HERE IN TERMS OF THE WHITE HOUSE TRYING TERMS OF THE WHITE HOUSE TRYING TO BASICALLY LOCK DOWN THE TO BASICALLY LOCK DOWN THE EVIDENCE ABOUT THE PRESIDENT’S EVIDENCE ABOUT THE PRESIDENT’S BEHAVIOR HERE, IMPROPERLY BEHAVIOR HERE, IMPROPERLY CLASSIFYING THIS MATERIAL OR CLASSIFYING THIS MATERIAL OR MOVING IT OR MAKING SURE THAT MOVING IT OR MAKING SURE THAT THE RECORDS WERE NOT CORRECT, THE RECORDS WERE NOT CORRECT, DELIBERATELY TO TRY TO PREVENT DELIBERATELY TO TRY TO PREVENT PEOPLE FROM KNOWING EITHER PEOPLE FROM KNOWING EITHER INSIDE THE GOVERNMENT OR INSIDE THE GOVERNMENT OR ULTIMATELY IN THIS KIND OF ULTIMATELY IN THIS KIND OF IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDING KNOWING IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDING KNOWING AN ACCURATE RECORD OF WHAT AN ACCURATE RECORD OF WHAT HAPPENED, DO YOU BELIEVE THE HAPPENED, DO YOU BELIEVE THE IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDINGS WILL BE IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDINGS WILL BE ABLE TO GET TO THE BOTTOM OF ABLE TO GET TO THE BOTTOM OF THAT? THAT? ARE THESE PROCESSES IN THE WHITE ARE THESE PROCESSES IN THE WHITE HOUSE LEAVE ENOUGH OF A TRAIL HOUSE LEAVE ENOUGH OF A TRAIL THAT INVESTIGATORS WILL BE ABLE THAT INVESTIGATORS WILL BE ABLE TO FIND IT? TO FIND IT?>>I’M NOT SURE, RACHEL.>>I’M NOT SURE, RACHEL. THAT’S A GREAT QUESTION. THAT’S A GREAT QUESTION. I DON’T KNOW THE ANSWER. I DON’T KNOW THE ANSWER. IT WOULD BE HARD — I HAD READ IT WOULD BE HARD — I HAD READ MULTIPLE TRANSCRIPTS IN MY TIME MULTIPLE TRANSCRIPTS IN MY TIME AT THE WHITE HOUSE. AT THE WHITE HOUSE. IT WOULD BE HARD FOR ME TO IT WOULD BE HARD FOR ME TO RETRACE LIKE WHO IS THE ONE THAT RETRACE LIKE WHO IS THE ONE THAT ACTUALLY DID IT FINAL EDITS. ACTUALLY DID IT FINAL EDITS. USUALLY IT’S THE DIRECTOR IN USUALLY IT’S THE DIRECTOR IN CHARGE, RIGHT? CHARGE, RIGHT? USUALLY IT WOULD BE ME, THE USUALLY IT WOULD BE ME, THE SENIOR DIRECTOR AND MY SENIOR DIRECTOR AND MY DIRECTORS, THAT IS PEOPLE AT THE DIRECTORS, THAT IS PEOPLE AT THE LEVEL THAT COLONEL VINDMAN WAS LEVEL THAT COLONEL VINDMAN WAS SERVING THAT WOULD HAVE THE SERVING THAT WOULD HAVE THE FINAL SAY. FINAL SAY. THIS SOUNDS LIKE IT OBVIOUSLY THIS SOUNDS LIKE IT OBVIOUSLY WASN’T. WASN’T. BUT WHO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR BUT WHO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT, I DON’T KNOW HOW YOU WOULD THAT, I DON’T KNOW HOW YOU WOULD TRACE THAT. TRACE THAT. I DO THINK IT UNDERSCORES I DO THINK IT UNDERSCORES SOMETHING WE’VE TALKED ABOUT SOMETHING WE’VE TALKED ABOUT BEFORE. BEFORE. IF THIS WAS A PERFECT CALL AND IF THIS WAS A PERFECT CALL AND THERE’S NOTHING TO HIDE, WHY DID THERE’S NOTHING TO HIDE, WHY DID THEY PUT IT ON THIS SUPER SECRET THEY PUT IT ON THIS SUPER SECRET SERVER? SERVER? WHY ARE WE NOW LEARNING THAT WHY ARE WE NOW LEARNING THAT THEY DID NOT PUT IN FACTUALLY THEY DID NOT PUT IN FACTUALLY CORRECT CORRECTIONS THAT COLONEL CORRECT CORRECTIONS THAT COLONEL VINDMAN WAS TRYING TO PUT IN THE VINDMAN WAS TRYING TO PUT IN THE OFFICIAL RECORD? OFFICIAL RECORD?>>ONE OF THE REASONS I WANTED>>ONE OF THE REASONS I WANTED TO TALK TO YOU TONIGHT, SIR, IS TO TALK TO YOU TONIGHT, SIR, IS BECAUSE I KNOW FROM YOUR TWITTER BECAUSE I KNOW FROM YOUR TWITTER FEED TODAY YOU SAID YOU SERVED FEED TODAY YOU SAID YOU SERVED WITH COLONEL VINDMAN IN MOSKOW. WITH COLONEL VINDMAN IN MOSKOW. YOU CALLED HIM A PATRIOT AND A YOU CALLED HIM A PATRIOT AND A FIRST RATE MILITARY ATTACHE, ONE FIRST RATE MILITARY ATTACHE, ONE OF THE BEST ON THE TEAM. OF THE BEST ON THE TEAM. I WANT TO GIVE YOU A CHANCE TO I WANT TO GIVE YOU A CHANCE TO RESPOND TO THE ATTACKS ON HIM, RESPOND TO THE ATTACKS ON HIM, FROM SOME OF THE PRESIDENT’S FROM SOME OF THE PRESIDENT’S SUPPORTERS IN CONGRESS SUPPORTERS IN CONGRESS ESSENTIALLY QUESTIONING HIS ESSENTIALLY QUESTIONING HIS PATRIOTISM, DESCRIBING HIM OZ PATRIOTISM, DESCRIBING HIM OZ HAVING SOME SORT OF SUSPECT HAVING SOME SORT OF SUSPECT LOYALTIES BECAUSE HE’S FROM AN LOYALTIES BECAUSE HE’S FROM AN IMMIGRANT FAMILY. IMMIGRANT FAMILY.>>FIRST, RACHEL, I WANT TO>>FIRST, RACHEL, I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU ALREADY THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU ALREADY SAID ABOUT HIM BEFORE THE BREAK. SAID ABOUT HIM BEFORE THE BREAK. SECOND, WE LIVE IN A POLARIZED SECOND, WE LIVE IN A POLARIZED SOCIETY. SOCIETY. HERE AT STANFORD WE STUDY THE HERE AT STANFORD WE STUDY THE CAUSES OF POLARIZATION. CAUSES OF POLARIZATION. I PERSONALLY DEAL WITH IT. I PERSONALLY DEAL WITH IT. I KNOW YOU PERSONALLY DEAL WITH. I KNOW YOU PERSONALLY DEAL WITH. I FELT YESTERDAY WE REACHED A I FELT YESTERDAY WE REACHED A NEW LOW, HOWEVER. NEW LOW, HOWEVER. WHEN I SAY WHAT PEOPLE WERE WHEN I SAY WHAT PEOPLE WERE SAYING ABOUT DUAL LOYALTITIES, SAYING ABOUT DUAL LOYALTITIES, HYPHENATED AG HYPHENATED AG HYPHENATED HYPHENATED HYPHENATED ADJECTIVES AND EVEN HYPHENATED ADJECTIVES AND EVEN ONE SUGGESTION OF ESPIONAGE ONE SUGGESTION OF ESPIONAGE BECAUSE HE TALKS TO UKRAINIAN BECAUSE HE TALKS TO UKRAINIAN OFFICIALS, THAT’S IN HIS JOB OFFICIALS, THAT’S IN HIS JOB DESCRIPTION, BY THE WAY WORKING DESCRIPTION, BY THE WAY WORKING AT THE NATIONAL SECURITY AT THE NATIONAL SECURITY COUNSEL. COUNSEL. AND I FOUND IT COMPLETELY AND I FOUND IT COMPLETELY OUTRAGEOUS. OUTRAGEOUS. YOU KNOW, WHAT HAVE WE COME TO YOU KNOW, WHAT HAVE WE COME TO THAT PEOPLE THAT SIGN-UP TO THAT PEOPLE THAT SIGN-UP TO SERVE IN OUR COUNTRY IN HARMS SERVE IN OUR COUNTRY IN HARMS WAY, IN IRAQ AND ALSO THE WAY, IN IRAQ AND ALSO THE NATIONAL SECURITY COUNSEL AND IN NATIONAL SECURITY COUNSEL AND IN OUR EMBASSIES AND KIEV AND OUR EMBASSIES AND KIEV AND MOSKOW, WE’VE DONE THIS BEFORE MOSKOW, WE’VE DONE THIS BEFORE AND IT REALLY TROUBLES ME ANYONE AND IT REALLY TROUBLES ME ANYONE WOULD INSINUATE ANYTHING ABOUT WOULD INSINUATE ANYTHING ABOUT THAT. THAT. HE WAS A FIRST RATE MILITARY HE WAS A FIRST RATE MILITARY OFFICER AND HE WAS OUT STANDING OFFICER AND HE WAS OUT STANDING AND APPOINTED BECAUSE HE IS ONE AND APPOINTED BECAUSE HE IS ONE OF THE BEST AND BRIGHTEST. OF THE BEST AND BRIGHTEST. AND THE IDEA THAT SOMEONE WITH AND THE IDEA THAT SOMEONE WITH HIS RÉSUMÉ WOULD NOT SERVE THE HIS RÉSUMÉ WOULD NOT SERVE THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IS JUST UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IS JUST DISGUSTING. DISGUSTING. IT’S OUTRAGEOUS. IT’S OUTRAGEOUS. AND I WANT THOSE PEOPLE TO AND I WANT THOSE PEOPLE TO APOLOGIZE TO REMEMBER WHAT APOLOGIZE TO REMEMBER WHAT THEY’RE DOING WHEN THEY TAKE THEY’RE DOING WHEN THEY TAKE CHEAP SHOTS AT PEOPLE LIKE CHEAP SHOTS AT PEOPLE LIKE COLONEL VINDMAN WHEN THEY DON’T COLONEL VINDMAN WHEN THEY DON’T KNOW HIS BACKGROUND AND THEY KNOW HIS BACKGROUND AND THEY DON’T KNOW HIS HISTORY. DON’T KNOW HIS HISTORY.>>SIR, THANK YOU FOR BEING>>SIR, THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE. HERE. I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU TAKING I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU TAKING THE TIME. THE TIME.>>THANKS FOR LETTING ME SAY ALL

100 thoughts on “Vindman: Trump-Ukraine Call Record Omitted Biden-Related Mentions | Rachel Maddow | MSNBC

  1. All the incriminating evidence I put in the transcript is not there anymore……I'M SURE…..boy they are going hard to stop Trump…….FAKE NEWS

  2. look the turks are mongols
    the russians are tartars
    they are cut from the same cloth
    they are the ones called Gog and Magog and if you think I am delusional I am very serious

  3. unless the senate can see with clemency that is mercy all men are blind
    and though justice is blind in the mind it see all things
    in truth

  4. the president or commodus
    he does not give back to the people who gave to him
    what man is this to go over the house who gave him power
    he gives no tithes and the people praise his ignorance and they are led into tyranny

  5. that guy who say he for the people he don`t like black people
    he don`t give nobody poor anything but more work
    we have done enough

  6. Amazing how fast an anti Trump statement is released from the "secret closed door" hearing with no chance to factcheck or cross examine or defend against a witness because its "SECRET"!

  7. We knew someone had changed the transcript when it was released right after DOJ was given the Whistleblowers complaint. FAKE POTUS was trying to jump out in front … what has become a fast moving train.

  8. Typical Trump, if you say something against him or his reasoning his first go to thing is to impugn the persons reputation, especially those with obvious better moral ethics than him.

  9. Bush was right about him being the last Republican President , it's a sad time for America , dump the trash Trump Mafia now , make America great again with a real American hero .

  10. Trump continues to rage for us to read the call transcript. Well, Mr. President, release the actual transcript if it will clear you.

  11. you can call me Cicero
    the Senate must be run on the basis of survival of the people
    not for any particular enslavement
    we are the individual and we are right to treat the hunger justly with truth for to debate survival is to die

  12. Definitely a new LOW for this Kangaroo Administration to smear a patriot WAR veteran like LT COLONEL VIDMAN. Those people has no SHAME whatsoever. While Dumpt stuffed his mouth with hot dogs and burgers this guy out in the WAR ZONE PROTECTING our country along with other veterans. LOCK THIS ORANGE PARASITE UP ALREADY.

  13. America is turning into a dictator country like Russia and Venezuela. Please wake up and stop Trump and his minions or your future, your kids future will be doomed

  14. When Mulvaney admitted several times there was a quid pro quo on tv, he also mentioned that there was a tape that they had listened to in order to create the call summary.

  15. It makes sense now why he kept saying the call was perfect. Itโ€™s coz he edited them to make it look like itโ€™s perfect.

  16. As a US Veteran I found Laura Ingraham's comment's anti-american. When right is wrong and wrong is right? Is this how it is? Fux News is a pollutant. BOYCOTT SPONSERS OF FOX CORP!

  17. He's one of our best and brightest? So you ADMIT he's predisposed to hate president Trump, who is only liked by our worst and most stupid?? Haha! Got you!

  18. They are the "bad guys" "spies" "traitors" until they take out the biggest at-large terrorist leader since OBL. They are the "deep state" and "corrupt" until their years of asset development and intelligence gathering pinpoints a location, a reliable pattern of movements and habits from which a highly complex military operation can be orchestrated. " They are no angels " until they give highly valuable real- time intel at zero hour that launches that spectacular take down of Baghdati even as the same bloviating President crowing about "his" military, " his" CIA and "his" killing of said Terrorist target, coordinates with other dictators to slaughter thousands of their own elderly fathers, mothers, their women and children in an act of ethnic cleansing. Amazing the extent of crassness the Trump surrogates will stoop to to blindly defend the indefensible.

  19. oh please – you want a record of the all? ask Ukraine. trump doesn't understand video or audio recordings – that's pretty clear. people who do wrong things, try to cover it up or 'change history'. honest people aren't worried about anyone knowing their activities. trump supporters have split brain syndrome – they'll call accuse someone of espionage because they talk to a 'friendly' foreign country, yet the stable genius they pray to, is clearly in an UNfriendly leader's pocket. the concepts of irony and hypocrisy are totally lost on stupid people.

  20. THE ONLY OPTION TO SAVE AMERICA IS ARREST LAWLESS TRAITOR TRUMP AND HIS UNPATRIOTIC REPUBLICAN MINIONS – DEAD OR ALIVE !

    BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE AND BEFORE THEY TOTALLY DESTABILIZE AND DESTROY AMERICA !

  21. โ€œWhen the truth offends, we lie and lie until we can no longer remember it is even there. But it is still there… Every lie we tell incurs a debt to the truth. Soon or later, that debt is paid.โ€ Valery Legasov

  22. Anything and everything out of Boris Trumpโ€™s beak should be considered a LIE! People whoโ€™ve served this country with honor have pegged Trump as a dishonest individual, all his actions have been to benefit russia and his financial interests. Why are so many in the GOP ignoring Trumpโ€™s crimes? Could it be that they too have been funded by russia directly and indirectly? Follow the money; bet anything else hereโ€™s a barrel of Republicans working with russia for political and financial gain! LOCK THEM UP!!!!

  23. might be an idea to ask those knocking this man, to have a quick gander at the medals on his chest… and ask them for a photo of THEIR medals.

  24. More fake news. Read the transcripts for yourself. CNN is spinning and living again. Orders from Zucker to CNN employees, keep propagandizing about the fake news made up fable called impeachment.

  25. I couldn't believe it when I saw this guy. I was shocked that he was in uniform. How could anyone doubt him? I hope Durham is listening to all this crap. He can use it in his report about the russian inv.

  26. The call also mentioned crowdstrike. But they donโ€™t want to mention what crowdstrike was. And trump didnโ€™t bring up the Bidenโ€™s the Ukraine president did. Another key element they leave out.

  27. Trump is a traitor and lying sak of sht. Vindman confirms that trump lied about removal of incriminating statements in the transcript. The House has no choice, but to impeach this poor excuse for a president. Racist trump supporters will keep sucking on him even after he is impeached.

  28. Ok I am here now it's time to keep your Promise to me as God you promised me One Nation Under God indivisible & Justice for all I am willing to accept being President now if you are tiered of Fake People trying to make things right when that is my job, I am willing to pay all expenses of running my Government with Gold Tax free Employers will pay taxes to their Employees for my honor of paying for my Government! And paying for free Health Care Free Energy and Pure Drinking Water for all, Please accept my offer willingly if you want me to fix this World as I won't accept by force I will need your help and Support till I can open my Mine and get Gold flowing to complete my Promise to you as these Creep Show Presidents have devastated my ability to Open it sooner thanks. God for President Forever.

  29. War heroes Mueller, Taylor, Vindman, vs. Iran business partner Barr, lying Giuliani and Russian asset Trump, gee, who to believe???

  30. Those Trumpets are so backward. They're glorifying the traitor in the WH while demonizing real patriots who have contributed so much to this country.

    I wish we can strip their citizenships & ship them to Russia with Traitor Trump where their loyalty lies.

  31. It's a NATIONAL DISGRACE that NUMPTY TRUMPTY who is a DRAFT DODGER can try to call into question the Honour of a WAR VETERAN… REPUBLICANS should hang their heads in SHAME coz they're ALLOWING in to happen on THEIR WATCH

  32. So BSNBC….if this leaked testimony is accurate then he is saying others before him committed pergery which may include Schiff's whistleblower?

    ๐Ÿ™ˆ๐Ÿ™‰๐Ÿ™Š

    I took his testimony as "opinion" National Security matters. Biden is not a security matter.

  33. Aha… the 'smoking gun'! Assuming that Vindman's testimony is corroborated, this will be the 'high crime and misdemeanor' that the Republicant's cannot ignore–the absolute proof of a coordinated cover-up of Drumpf's "masterminded" [verb form–NOT a descriptor of Drumpf's mental acuity] attempted smear of a political rival by the head of a foreign country.

  34. Too bad for Trump…after more than 12,000 lies while in office…he has ZERO credibility.

    Bet he wishes he had some now.

  35. the mueller report was redacted and deliberately misrepresented. the phone call transcript was redacted and deliberately misrepresented. more #obstruction.

  36. Bureaucracy is the last bastion of the guilty.

    (It took me three tries to spell that word correctly. Man, "last" is a mouthful.)

  37. Ummm….. Dear Santa, as I've been such a good metrosexual all year, for Winterval could I please have a Presuhdent Gump doll and a bucket of water to wash him in upside-down?
    Anyway, must dash – The Easter Beagle wants his eggs back for next Thanksfornothinggiving….

  38. Why don't they just give the Trump a colouring book and leave the running of the country to people with integrity? We know how good he is with a sharpie.

  39. Wait a minute. In the confession Benedict Donald released it clearly said at the top that it was not a verbatim memo. That was already noted.

  40. 8:00 I instantly liked McFaul, from pretty much the first minute I encountered him as a guest on this show. But in this clip, he really excels himself, calling for an actual apology from those who treat loyalty as a bullwhip of obedience to the ruffian-come-recently overlords of discord and tumult.

  41. Notice all the โ€œmenโ€ against Trump appear to have low-T and are soy-betas that the Spartans would have thrown off a cliff at birth?

  42. Trump's criminal activity in both his private life, business life, and short political life knows no boundaries to the level of corruption and illegal activity he will commit against the citizenry and nation! Get rid of him!!!!!!!

  43. Military veterans HAVE PTSD FROM COMMITTING LEGAL MURDER in the name of freeeedom..he is conflicted by sworn authority s to gvt officials

  44. People who sign up to serve and have multiple, distinguishing awards vs those who pay for a doctor's note for bonespurs to avoid service. I am so tired of hearing the orange moron's name calling when someone doesn't say what he wants them to say. Children should not be in charge of the government but since he is a man (in the weakest sense of the word) he needs to act like an adult and he needs to have the law applied to his criminal activities and be charged according to adult standards. Never my president.

  45. The President's men are all great and very fine people
    Criminals, Mobsters, Rats and Sexual perpetrators

    War Heroes, Generals and great Statesmen are all losers to the draft dodger

    Guess who or what a 45th we are dealing with or stuck with

  46. That's the thing though, they DO know his background and history and they still take cheap shots at him. Any pretense of being pro-soldier or pro-veteran by the Republicans needs to stop after this administration. Attacking Vindman, attacking McCain, attacking the Kurds, attacking gold star families – all coming from a spoiled dodge drafting coward – lasping the benefits of veterans so they're sentenced to die due to lack of healthcare (thanks McConnell! you never risked your life but you get excellent healthcare courtesy of the taxpayers. Bet u would never vote against that!!) – shouldn't all this disgusting, self-serving behavior mean that they can no longer brand themselves as pro-serviceman? Pro-military, sure, but not pro-servicemen. Why are Republican voters ok with this????

  47. Trump and his buffoons once said this is the most transparent administration there have ever been. RIGHT!!!They are so transparent they need to omit pertinent information and hide them away in special vaults. Democracy has fallen. THANKS REPUBLICANS, you have done your damnation to tear down the U.S. to cover up for Trump.

  48. Trump's server needs to be revealed. That is his Dorian Gray portrait. American hackers if you're listening get Trump's server.

  49. It is not entirely clear to me under what conditions any criticism of Trump is ok with the GOP. How far down the drain must we head before someone innthe GOP will admit that maybe there is a point here somewhere ๐Ÿ˜ฑ

  50. Wow, what a shock. A Zionist thug from the U.S. Armed Services is making up lies about Pres. Trump and a tool like presstitute Madow is running with it after her failed fake Russian scam flopped.

  51. Who do you believe? The man who has a Purple Heart with over 30 years in the military, or a bad business man who bought his way into office? Vindman is a true patriot

  52. He is one of many but can be imbued to become or want to be categorized only he can act or be salty or want the best for others and choose who the others are and if the others are apart of something bigger polarization is just a construct because we perceive it to be true or false to a degree government is different

  53. Attacks on credible Patriots, spin on the Truth or desperate attempts to intimidate witnesses are futile because all the evidence points out to 'Abuse of Power'. As soon as the Open Hearing is in process, the American people will be the judge.
    Republicans { including the 'Gang of 4' : Gulliani, Barr, Pompeo & Pence } who continue to support their nasty Moron are complicit in trying to deceive the American people. The 'Gang of 4' in Mao`s China had to face justice – IMPRISONMENT !
    Repent, be honest and honour the American people.

  54. Mr. President Trump, make America great again, without Democrats, that would be good for the world !

    Greetings from Germany.

  55. Listen to McFaul, watching some Fox pundits I got a sinking feeling because they would even go as far as to say the things about Col. Vindman. What has this country sunk to? That it is ok to smear someone that the pundit knew nothing about to prop up lying Donald Trump.

  56. Good Ole donnie thrump…American traitor, con man, autocrat and dicktaker wanna be. Thrump is a sadistic hypocrite, weakling and bonified Punk and everybody knows it. He will die a sad and lonely being.

  57. Hi Rachel Anne.๐Ÿ‘‹๐Ÿป.
    Exceptional reporting, Rachel.๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿป๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘.
    Keep on digging, Rachel.๐Ÿ‘.
    ๐Ÿ‘‰๐Ÿ‘‰Proceed democrats, proceed.๐Ÿ‘โ˜บ.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *